Can You Grow Plants in Water?
About the Experiment
Hydroponics is the technique of growing plants using a water-based nutrient solution rather than soil. Hydroponic production systems are typically used by small farmers and commercial enterprises, but they are also being increasingly used in urban areas like cities where there may not be enough fertile land to grow crops.
Hydroponics allows farmers to grow their fruits and vegetables in a controlled environment, but it also entails using more energy and possibly more water. How does hydroponics affect the growing process, and how do the fruits and vegetables taste? Let’s find out by comparing hydroponics with traditional growing in soil outdoors.
Details
Age: 7-8 | Time: 3-4 Weeks | Difficulty: Moderate
What You Will Need
For the Hydroponics
-
6-12 small cups
-
Styrofoam board (about 1” thick)
-
Sponges or rinsed clay pebbles
-
Hydroponic nutrient solution (premixed,
kid safe) -
Plastic container (not clear)
For the Soil
-
6-12 small pots or cups with
drainage holes -
Potting mix with slow releasing
fertilizers (not gardening soil) -
Watering can or squeeze bottle
For Both
-
Seeds of leafy green vegetables
or herbs, such as leaf lettuce,
basil, arugula, or microgreens -
Water
-
Ruler, labels, tape, marker
Let’s Do This!
Prepare the Hydroponics
-
Fill the container with water.
-
Cut the Styrofoam board to fit the container and cut holes in the board to fit the plant cups. Add a few more small holes inside each cup place holder to give the plant roots room to grow.
-
Ask an adult to drill or cut a small hole in each cup.
-
Ask an adult to cut the sponges into a small square to place inside the cups. Form a hole in the sponges for seed germination. Or place the pebbles on the bottom of the cup.
-
Ask a parent to help dilute the nutrient solution per instructions on the label and volume of water in the container.
Prepare the Soil
-
Fill the pots 4-6” with moist potting mix (pre-wet so it’s evenly damp).
-
Make a small hole and plant the seeds at label depth (about 1/4 inch).
-
Water gently so soil is evenly moist, not soggy.
Planting and Care
-
Use the same seed variety for the hydroponics and soil.
-
Plant 1-2 seeds per cup/pot and then cover them from light for 3-4 days under room temperature. You can cover with aluminum foil if you like. Thin to 1 plant after germination.
-
Once seedlings are germinated, place the hydroponic cups close to a window with some hours of available sunlight (or you can use an LED light bulb). Place the soil cups outside in available full sunlight. If there is a chance of frost, bring the soil cups in at night.
-
For the hydroponics, add more nutrient solution and water if the water drops too low. For the soil, water just a little every day; avoid soaking the cups.
-
Observe all plants for 3-4 weeks. Use a spreadsheet to track results, such as plant height, fresh weight, and food taste between plants in the hydroponic and soil experiments.
Observations
-
Which plants grew faster and fuller using the hydroponics technique?
-
Which plants grew faster and fuller using the soil technique?
-
Which technique produced the best results overall?
-
Which technique was easier to follow throughout the process?
-
What aspect of the experiment surprised you?
-
Do you think you can grow your own fruits and vegetables using hydroponics?
Want to learn more about hydroponics research? Check out this page: https://www.ars.usda.gov/research/project/?accnNo=443702
Download the printable "Can You Grow Plants in Water?" project PDF: https://www.ars.usda.gov/ARSUserFiles/oc/AgLab/projects/GrowPlantsInWater/Can-you-Grown-Plants-in-Water.pdf